Comment policy
Draft for the owner's legal read. This page is written in plain English but has not been reviewed by a lawyer. It must be read and approved before the site goes public.
The discussion under the paper is for testing it. Rebuttals are welcome; that is the point. These rules keep it useful.
What we ask
- Be civil. Argue with the claim, not the person. No insults, threats or harassment.
- Cite sources for factual claims. A link in the source field of a rebuttal is the best way to be taken seriously.
- No spam or promotion. That includes courses, signals, referral links and anything that sells something.
- No personal data about anyone, including yourself. Do not post addresses, phone numbers or account details.
- Stay on topic. Comments are about the paper. Questions can reach a bit wider.
- Plain text only. HTML is refused. At most two links in the text itself.
- This is not a place for individual investment advice, and nothing here is financial advice.
How moderation works
- Every post is held until the author has read it. Nothing is shown automatically.
- The author decides what to publish, reply to, or decline. A post may be declined for any reason, including that it is off topic, and there may be no explanation.
- The author may reply publicly. A rebuttal that turns out to be right leads to a correction, listed in the corrections log. A reader is only named there if they agree.
- Disagreement is not a reason to decline a post. Rule-breaking is.
Anonymous posting
You do not need an account. The display name is optional and is not checked, so do not read anything into a name. A few names (such as the author's) are reserved.
Removing a post
If you posted something and want it removed, say so in a new comment that quotes the first words of your post, and the author will remove it when it is reviewed. Because there are no accounts, we cannot otherwise verify who wrote a post.